It's easy enough to run a good workshop when students and teachers are excited and involved. But year after year, the students in this school are quiet, stifled, repressed. By the end of the hour-long session, they begin to loosen up, but getting to the end of that hour can feel like the hardest work I've ever done. Meanwhile, the teachers, the students, my co-teacher watch me snarling myself into a mess. It's a bad feeling, but instructive . . . not just as a demonstration of the perils of the classroom but also as a reminder of the immensity of imaginative loss that can afflict an entire population. It's heartbreaking, really--a school, stocked with perfectly nice teachers and a decent building, that nonetheless year after year turns out students who don't know how to let their minds wander.
Having Patrick alongside me was good, for a number of reasons. He is a serious writer and reader in a genre that isn't mine, so we share a similar mission and mindset about the work but have disparate goals. He's also interested in being the kind of writing teacher whose focus is connecting the vocation with the human being--which is not a usual approach among people who are working with kids. Most importantly, though, his daughter attends this school. And he worries and cares, because this is his town, and her town. And despite all the ways in which we might love and respect the inarticulate difficulties of being citizens in Somerset County, when they begin to weigh down our own shining, curious, questing children, we are afraid.
Last week a correspondent from the Waterville Morning Sentinel sat at my kitchen table and interviewed me for a forthcoming article in the paper. Among other topics, she introduced activism: "Your work doesn't seem obviously activist," she said, and I felt surprised, and a little embarrassed about how insular my writing can be. No, I don't talk much about wars or oil spills or poisonous anti-intellectualism or human rights, though I'm distressed about them all, though I vote the straight bleeding-heart-liberal ticket. But as the reporter and I talked, I began to realize that, in fact, if I am an activist about anything, it's about these school writing workshops. When I have students who ask me, in all perplexed honesty, "Is it okay if I make this up?" . . . when I have parents who tell me, "I had no idea my daughter had so many feelings," I do see that the writing matters, that thinking matters, that the adventure of imagination matters.
So even though I kind of hate this middle school gig, I'll do it every year I'm asked: because if Patrick and I don't stand up in the middle of that room of silent children and say, "Hey, kids! Telling lies matters!" I fear that no one else will ever let them know.
5 comments:
PLease do keep telling them. When I look out on the bright shining faces in my own class and see sparkle and then when I actually read pieces I only wish I could have written, I know it is worth all the word logging.
What you're doing when you go into the classroom is something we all owe our children, a lesson what words mean and can do.
yup getting them to tell lies is as important as getting them to recognize the truth, yet one is seen as a patriotic virtue and the other sin, when they are so related one can't do one without the other. Well one can, but not for "good." And I mean that ambiguously.
These reflections resonate strongly with my own experiences teaching writing at the college level. There is, I suspect, at all levels a fear associated with articulating oneself: writing entails confronting not only our sense of incompetence with words (which seems to be pretty deep and pervasive -- Americans are acculturated to shun failure), but also the mystery of what the words, once we find them, will loose from us. Though there is such surfeit of them out there in our so-called Information Age, words are still dangerous. (This is Stan Walker, BTW -- I haven't set up a Google account yet, but I didn't want this post to be anonymous.)
Stan, I'm really glad to hear from you. In many ways, I think college-level writing reaches a new level of stultification: students are literally trained out of even going so far as to say "I" in a sentence. It's sickens me to watch writers become convinced that their personal perceptions and curiosities are unprofessional and un-intellectual.
Post a Comment