Pages

Friday, January 29, 2016

"Education can substitute for experience but experience cannot be substituted for education."

The above sentence appears in a job description for a part-time entry-level editorial/administrative opening at a university MFA program. I don't think I need to tell you how it makes me feel. I will, however, point out that the rhetorical balance of the sentence is terrible: why repeat the verbs but bulk up the second half with a clumsy tense change? Possibly some experience with sentences would have helped.

I try not to be cynical about the arts and education, but sometimes I can't help myself. Dear friends who "only" have experience: keep using it.

* * *

If you're in the Dover-Foxcroft area tonight, stop by Pastimes Pub and say hello. My band Doughty Hill will be performing, starting at about 6:30. The food is good; the ceilings are high; and there's an old bank vault you can peek into. We'll be playing some new songs and revisiting a pile of old friends--for instance, this one: Howlin' Wolf's "Built for Comfort."


* * *

Call it a gesture no one understood,
neither dismissal nor assent, but the thing
left midair when his juggling skewed.

--from Richard Foerster's "His Wasted Life," in River Road (2015)

1 comment:

  1. Yet again, I wish I lived close enough to hear your band live and to visit with you!!!

    As a long time teacher, I'd have to say that experience greatly aces education. Experience usually helps us survive our own stupidity and our own strengths.

    ReplyDelete

Thanks for responding. I'll post your comment soon, as long as you're not a troll.